The Healing Power of Plants

Previous blogs have mentioned the H.O.P.E. Project 1 , particularly the two films, H.O.P.E. What You Eat Matters 2017/2018 2 3 . In this brief blog, I just want to draw your attention to a recent story which demonstrates the power of plants and exercise to fight disease – in this case, neurofibromatosis, a cancer where the tumours grow in the nervous system.

In the first episode of their new short film series, ‘Plant Power Stories’, the producers of H.O.P.E. look at individuals from many different backgrounds, all of whom have one thing in common: their lives have completely transformed by adopting a plant-based lifestyle.

D Anthony Evans -The Film

The following short film is the first part of Plant Power Stories, featuring the inspirational story of an American man called D Anthony Evans.

D’s Story

As a child, at age 6, D was diagnosed with neurofibromatosis, a rare genetically inherited disorder where tumours grow on nerve tissue. Often benign, they can become malignant, resulting in an aggressive form of cancer.

Since his diagnosis he has undergone 11 surgeries (including nine 9-hour surgeries) to remove 385 tumours.

In 2012, D was diagnosed with this aggressive form of cancer and was given six months to live.

The Power of Plants & Exercise

Now, over 5 years later, he’s not just surviving – he’s positively thriving. Anyone looking at D’s outward appearance would never guess that he’d suffered from a life-threatening cancer which was predicted to claim his life.

He attributes his survival to his lifestyle change – eating a completely plant-based diet, intensive physical exercise, and a positive mental attitude.

He’s now helping others as an inspirational speaker, author, strength coach and at-risk youth mentor, serving as an Ambassador Constituent Team Lead for the American Cancer Society.

‘Plant Power Stories’

This series of films (more to come in the future) aims to inform and inspire people about the power of a healthy, plant-based diet and conscious lifestyle.

The Aims of H.O.P.E.

The Project: H.O.P.E. stands for Healing Of Planet Earth, and the central aim of ‘H.O.P.E. The Project’ is to create mass awareness of the vital importance of a whole food, plant-based lifestyle.

Final thoughts

These are the sort of inspirational stories that can give hope to so many people who might be suffering from diseases they think are untreatable – struggling to find a way through their pain and suffering, without even being aware that simple lifestyle changes are able to pack a punch which is often more powerful than that provided by pharmaceuticals and surgical interventions.

Our bodies want to heal themselves. Our bodies can heal themselves. But they need to be provided with the right nutrients (and protected from the wrong nutrients) in order to do so.


References

  1. The H.O.P.E. Project []
  2. I H.O.P.E. You Watch & Share This Film []
  3. Videos []

Arthritis & Plant-Based Foods

I know from personal experience within my family that arthritis can be an excruciatingly painful disease which imposes significant limits on the quality of one’s life. At first inspection, it seems too good to be true that making simple dietary and lifestyle changes could significantly improve the symptoms of arthritis; but delving into the research (and eating the diet myself) has shown that it’s possible, not only to reduce arthritic pain, but to remove the major symptoms completely, allowing the body to heal itself where it can.

What is Arthritis?

It’s really a group of diseases causing swollen and painful joints.

Osteoarthritis (OA) is usually a gradual degeneration of joint cartilage and underlying bone which is most common from middle age onward – indeed, OA is “the most frequent cause of physical disability among older adults” in the world 1 . It results in stiffness and pain, especially in the hip, knee, and thumb joints. It’s commonly thought that OA is merely unavoidable wear and tear, but this is not the case. In fact, it’s an active joint disease with a prominent inflammatory component.

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is where the body itself attacks the joints in a much more aggressive manner. As a chronic progressive disease, the inflammation it causes in the joints can result in painful deformity and immobility, especially in the fingers, wrists, feet, and ankles.

Genes & Arthritis

There are genetic predispositions within families, making it more or less likely that a person may develop RA. However, just because there’s a genetic predisposition, it does not necessarily mean that those genes have to be triggered and, hence, dictate the course of events in a person’s life.

Inflammation & Arthritis

We’ve already looked 2 at how the foods we eat can significantly affect the inflammation within our bodies. There is strong evidence that dietary changes can help to prevent the development of arthritis and, if it has already developed, to reduce inflammation and, thereby, potentially to eliminate the pain and stiffness altogether. Basically, get rid of the foods that spark the inflammatory responses within the joints, and you get rid of the inflammation.

A survey of more than 1,000 arthritis patients revealed that red meat, sugar, fat, salt, caffeine, and nightshade plants (e.g., tomatoes, eggplant) most commonly worsen the condition. Research also shows that dairy protein may make symptoms worse.3

Research on Diet & Osteoarthritis

A 2012 study 4 considered that dietary changes along with increased physical exercise represents the best first-line option in preventing and treating OA: “Healthy living can be exploited to reduce inflammation, oxidative stress, and related pain and disability and improve patients’ overall health. This approach aligns with evidence-based best practice and holds the promise of eliminating or reducing chronic low-grade inflammation, attenuating disease progression, reducing weight, maximizing health by minimizing a patient’s risk or manifestations of other lifestyle-related conditions hallmarked by chronic low-grade inflammation, and reducing the need for medications and surgery. This approach provides an informed cost effective basis for prevention, potential reversal, and management of signs and symptoms of chronic osteoarthritis.”

 

A 2015 study 5 considered whether people with OA could benefit from dietary changes. They found that those eating a WFPB diet were able to report a significant decrease in their OA pain – and this was in just 2 weeks. At the end of the six-week study, they also reported more energy and better physical functioning, too. The study concluded: “…results suggest that a whole-foods, plant-based diet significantly improves self-assessed measures of functional status among osteoarthritis patients.

Osteoarthritis & Obesity

We’ve already looked at the powerful evidence 6 7 8 showing that the best, safest and most sustainable diet to prevent and treat obesity consists of moving away from all animal and processed food and replacing them with whole plant foods. But what about the relationship between OA and obesity?

A 2018 study 9 considered the evidence for a strong link between obesity and OA. It concluded: “With excess adiposity appearing to underlie the metabolic factors now recognized as being integral to OA, particularly of the hand and knee 10 11 , dietary modification to achieve weight reduction where appropriate, together with increased physical activity, are the strongest evidence-based recommendations.

Obesity is a significant risk factor for developing OA. And it’s not just a matter of obesity putting more pressure on the joints. Within the joints, fatty tissue represents a potent source of pro-inflammatory chemicals that actively increase cartilage breakdown. When you lose weight, there are fewer of these chemicals and the symptoms of OA improve. It’s not rocket science to realise that the modern Western diet is going to supply the body with ample amounts of these pro-inflammatory chemicals which, in turn, will build up and put increased stress on joints.

Which Foods Fight Osteoarthritis?

Whilst I would always suggest that it’s best to focus on eating a varied and balanced plant diet, rather than merely focusing on the latest individual ‘miracle’ foods that regularly hit the media, there are some specific plant foods that research has indicated are particularly good for preventing and treating OA, including:

  • turmeric curcumin 12
  • ginger 13
  • sesame seeds 14
  • rose hips 15
  • soy protein 16
  • coriander/cilantro 17
  • acai berries 18
  • sulforaphane in broccoli/cabbage leaves 19

A 2012 study 20 looked at some of the mechanisms (particularly the molecular antiosteoarthritic mechanisms) involved in how OA may be prevented and treated by the polyphenols in common plant foods, including:

  • turmeric curcumin
  • epigallocatechin gallate 21 and green tea extract
  • resveratrol 22
  • nobiletin 23 and citrus fruits
  • pomegranate
  • genistein 24 and soy protein

 

Research on Diet & Rheumatoid Arthritis

It’s been known for some time that diet can have a notable affect on RA.

A 2000 study 25 looked at whether following a raw vegan diet rich in antioxidants and fibre could decrease joint stiffness and pain in patients with RA. The study stated: “In conclusion the rheumatoid patients subjectively benefited from the vegan diet rich in antioxidants, lactobacilli and fibre, and this was also seen in objective measures.”

A 2001 study 26 found a gluten-free, vegan diet was of significant benefit in improving the signs and symptoms of RA, with the authors concluding: “…this benefit may be related to a reduction in immunoreactivity to food antigens eliminated by the change in diet.

A 2001 systematic review 27 concluded that fasting followed by a vegetarian or vegan diet might be useful in the treatment of RA: “The pooling of these studies showed a statistically and clinically significant beneficial long-term effect. Thus, available evidence suggests that fasting followed by vegetarian diets might be useful in the treatment of RA.

A 2002 study 28 looked at the how a very low-fat vegan diet would affect individuals with moderate-to-severe RA. It only took 4 weeks on the diet to see significant improvements in the following:

  • morning stiffness
  • RA pain
  • joint tenderness, and
  • joint swelling

Which Foods Fight Rheumatoid Arthritis?

Whatever helps to prevent/treat OA would, you’d imagine, also help with RA. Again, picking out specific plants or phytochemicals is not the ideal approach, compared with simply eating a balanced and varied WFPB diet; but, as mentioned above, there are some specific foods which it’s worth pointing out have been shown as potentially helpful in preventing/treating RA, including:

  • turmeric 29 30
  • rosehip 31
  • coriander/cilantro 32
  • sour cherries & pomegranates 33
  • ginger 34
  • green tea 35
  • parsley 36

Of course, an astonishingly wide range of inflammatory-fighting polyphenols are in all fruit and vegetables, and so any balanced WFPB diet will help to inhibit platelet activity which is associated with inflammation.

What Mechanisms Are Involved?

Things are changing in our view of arthritis. The question of just how central inflammation and immune responses are in the causation and prolongation of both OA and RA is an unfolding journey of discovery. It would appear to me as though the research is heading towards concluding that the role of immune responses and inflammation – and, hence, the primary role of diet in preventing both of these bodily reactions – is a lot more important in the pathogenesis of arthritis in general.

For instance, one study 37 comments: “Osteoarthritis (OA) has traditionally been classified as a noninflammatory arthritis; however, the dichotomy between inflammatory and degenerative arthritis is becoming less clear with the recognition of a plethora of ongoing immune processes within the OA joint and synovium.

Naturally, if the joint defences (the cartilage) are chronically damaged, any excessive exercise or trauma to that joint will exacerbate joint damage; however, studies are revealing that it’s the food we eat, to some not-insignificant extent, that causes cartilage damage (or fails to protect the cartilage in the first place).

One study 38 looked at the role of WFPB diets in the treatment of OA, describing OA as: “...a group of mechanical abnormalities involving the degradation of articular cartilage and subchondral bone in the joints….A variety of causes including hereditary, developmental, metabolic, and mechanical etiologies may initiate the process of cartilage loss. As cartilage thins, bony surfaces become less well-protected and bone may be exposed or damaged. Regional muscles may experience atrophy and ligaments become more lax as a result of decreased movement secondary to pain.”

The same study concludes: “The present and earlier studies provide further evidence for the beneficial effects of WFPB diets in many patients with OA. We hope that the results from the current study will encourage an increased appreciation and clinical evaluation of dietary variables and that WFPB diet therapies are recommended as an adjunct to standard medical management of this debilitating chronic disease.”

In a podcast entitled “Healthy Joints39 , Dr Greger reinforces this by analysing how a plant-based diet protects our joints against arthritis. The common feature throughout, is the association between joint damage (be it via cartilage breakdown/loss of bone density or via autoimmune responses) and the consumption of animal foods.

In one of his short videos entitled “Preventing Arthritis40 , Dr Greger draws a clear link between the pathogenesis of arthritis and the consumption of animal foods: “...eating meat—even a tiny amount—may dramatically increase our risk of developing degenerative arthritis. Even eating meat less than once a week may trigger arthritis. My patients will say things to me like, they only smoke x number of cigarettes, and my response is always that any amount of smoking is too much.”

Plenty of other research supports this view of the link between consuming animal foods and developing arthritis, with one study 41 concluding: “Greater meat consumption is associated with a higher prevalence of degenerative arthritis and soft tissue disorders in both male and female subjects of this population…

Dr Greger on Arthritis & Animal Foods

Dr Greger mentions 42 one particular case: “…a case report of a woman eating eggs, dairy, and meat with joint inflammation so bad she was on chemo and steroids—until she stopped ingesting animal products, and her symptoms disappeared when she just ate plant proteins. She could turn on and off her disease like a light switch. It even says how she ate meat the night before her doctor’s appointment, just to show the doctor that she really did have bad arthritis…

When susceptible people put all these foreign animal proteins in their body, one of two things may happen. When we nibble on the cartilage at the end of a chicken’s leg, our immune system may react to these foreign cartilage proteins by producing anti-cartilage antibodies that may get confused, and start attacking our own cartilage. That’s what they mean by meat-induced joint attack. The other possibility is that even if there are no cross-reactivity confusions, the immune complexes formed by the meat proteins and our antibodies may migrate into our joints and trigger inflammation that way.

Animal Fats & Arthritis

Dr Neil Barnard posits 43 the possibility that animal fats may have a causal relationship with arthritis: “Plant-based diets are often lower in fat and contain different kinds of fat than diets with animal products. For example, many whole plant foods have an optimal ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fats. Healthful weight loss from eating a vegan diet is also anti-inflammatory, further helping cool irritated joints.

Dr Barnard goes on to provide two food lists – one that’s thought to help and the other that’s thought to exacerbate the symptoms of arthritis. He suggests that you eat an abundance of foods on the former list and avoid all foods on the latter list. Any foods that do not appear on either list, he suggests can be eaten freely. He also suggests that sufferers monitor if there are any foods that clearly trigger symptoms. These should be removed from the diet to see if their removal improves symptoms.

Foods That Help Alleviate Arthritis Symptoms

These ‘pain-safe foods’ virtually never contribute to arthritis, headaches, or other painful conditions:

  • brown rice
  • cooked green vegetables
  • cooked orange vegetables
  • cooked yellow vegetables
  • cooked or dried non-citrus fruits
Common Trigger Foods To Be Avoided
  • animals foods (this means all fish, meat, eggs and dairy)
  • alcoholic beverages (especially red wine)
  • monosodium glutamate (MSG)
  • aspartame (NutraSweet)
Foods Reported As Potential Trigger Foods In Some Sufferers
  • caffeinated drinks (coffee, tea, and colas)
  • nitrites [Shown to be responsible in animal foods, but research 44 45 46 does not appear to support this in plant-foods.]
  • chocolate [Research 47 48 seems to suggest this does not apply to plain unsweetened cocoa – it’s the usual sweetened dairy chocolate that’s the problem.]
  • citrus Fruits [Some recent research 49 questions whether this is indeed the case, since there may be a protective aspect of citrus fruits for those with arthritis, particularly RA.]
  • wheat [There’s uncertainty here about whether it’s the processed wheat in white bread and pastries that’s the issue. I suspect that wholegrains do not present the same potential to trigger arthritis symptoms, since other research 50 includes them in the anti-inflammatory diet suggested for arthritis sufferers.]
  • nuts and peanuts [Alternative research 51 suggests that nuts and seeds are beneficial for arthritis sufferers.]
  • tomatoes [Arthritis Research UK state 52 that they know of no research proving a link between tomatoes and arthritis. I guess this also relates to other nightshade veg.]
  • onions [Other research 53 considers alliums (including onions, garlic and leeks) to be protective against arthritis.]
  • corn [I’ve found no research that supports the notion that whole corn (either fresh on a cob or dried whole) has negative effects on arthritis. Once again, I suggest it’s when the corn is eaten as an isolated oil or within fast-food snacks that problems arise.]
  • apples [This is an odd one, since research 54 55 indicates that apples are excellent for both reducing inflammation and providing a rich supply of easily-absorbed vitamin C and other phytonutrients.]
  • bananas [Comments by Arthritis Research UK 56 exemplify the confusion over bananas and arthritis by saying that there’s anecdotal evidence both for and against bananas for relieving arthritis symptoms. As far as I can see, there’s no solid research evidence either way.]

My suspicion with some of the above ‘triggers’ is that they have become anecdotally associated with increasing arthritic symptoms rather than because there is any convincing research evidence.

Of course, this is not to claim that these foods cannot trigger arthritis symptoms in some people, but this appears to be the typical situation where people focus on one particular ‘bad boy’ food rather than their whole diet – often in the hope that, thereby, they won’t have to radicalise their diet and remove favourite food (meat, fast-food, snacks, confectionery, processed foods) to which they are virtually addicted and which they can’t imagine living without. More of this below in relation to wholism vs reductionism.

Joint Damage in Athletes

We looked previously 57 58 59 in some detail at how a plant-based diet protects athletes against joint and muscle damage, as well as being effective in helping to heal the body more quickly from exercise-related injury. Thus, it would make sense that making the right choice between a diet consisting of pro-inflammatory animal-foods or of anti-inflammatory plant-foods may be a primary factor in the pathogenesis and development of both OA and RA. This is made more probable when we take into account how plant-foods are shown 60 to provide such strong support for the body’s immune system, for instance through producing the ideal microbiome in our guts.

Gout – A Form of Arthritis

In a previous blog specifically on gout 61 , we looked in great detail at how the consumption of animal-foods is perhaps the major cause of this excruciating condition; conversely, we saw that transitioning to a wholefood plant-based diet (as well as making other lifestyle changes, such as cutting out alcohol) prevents and treats gout more effectively than current medications – and without all the associated side-effects of the latter.

Wholism vs Reductionism

Once again, it’s possible to pan out on this whole topic and conjecture that a more wholistic approach to disease prevention and treatment – one that would deal with the vast range of seemingly interlinked conditions, such as obesity, diabetes, heart-disease, hypertension, immune disease and inflammatory diseases – is the way to kill more than one disease with just one diet.

As discussed in a previous blog 62 , modern medicine appears to have fallen into a reductionist trap, where drug companies (and thereby medical practitioners) are on a constant race to find one specific drug to treat – what they think is – one specific disease. An alternative paradigm is that all medical conditions are linked in complex ways within our bodies and, since we are what we eat, the thing that most dramatically and directly affects this complex of bodily conditions is the food we put in our mouths.

Final Thoughts

Six of One or Half a Dozen of the Other

So, to some extent, the most important general questions might not be whether arthritis is caused by animal protein-induced autoimmune attack in the joints or by the animal proteins/fats themselves attacking the joints; rather, perhaps we should be stepping back and looking at the elephant in the room – the animal foods themselves. This is particularly the case when animal foods are eaten to excess in highly processed form, as is the norm within the Western diet.

Maybe Confusion is a Good Thing Sometimes

If the above has left you with a degree of confusion about which specific foods are good or bad for the prevention/treatment of different forms of arthritis, then maybe that’s not as bad a thing as it might at first appear.

After all, we only understand a small fraction of the incredibly complex interactions of the tens of thousands of nutrients in foods – and this is apart from our relative ignorance of the precise ways in which these interactions affect the tissues, organs, processes and trillions of interrelated cells within our bodies. In the above-mentioned blog, Wholism vs Reductionism 62 , this was well-demonstrated by looking at just one diagrammatic representation of the partial metabolic processes involved in one single cell:

Don’t even try to read this, let alone understand it.

As Professor T Colin Campbell adds 63 :

The fact that each nutrient passes through such a maze of reaction pathways suggests that each nutrient also is likely to participate in multiple health and disease outcomes. The one nutrient/one disease relationship implied by reductionism, although widely popular, is simply incorrect. Every nutrient-like chemical that enters this complex system of reactions creates a rippling effect that may extend far into the pool of metabolism. And with every bite of food we eat, there are tens and probably hundreds of thousands of food chemicals entering this metabolism pool more or less simultaneously.

So, we’re faced with the same choice in terms of arthritis as we are with all the non-communicable diet-related diseases which are growing at terrifying rates within our populations: do we wait until the media, health authorities, politicians and food manufacturers/retailers own up to the reality of plant-based diets being the optimal choice for humans, or do we take our own health in our hands and choose the WFPB dietary route for ourselves today?


References

  1. T. Neogi, Y. Zhang. Epidemiology of osteoarthritis. Rheum. Dis. Clin. North Am. 2013 39(1):1 – 19. []
  2. Depression is Linked to Inflammation []
  3. Focus on plant-based foods to ease arthritis pain. []
  4. E. Dean, R. G. Hansen. Prescribing optimal nutrition and physical activity as first-line interventions for best practice management of chronic low-grade inflammation associated with osteoarthritis: Evidence synthesis. Arthritis. 2012 2012:560634. []
  5. Clinton CM, O’Brien S, Law J, Renier CM, Wendt MR. Whole-foods, plant-based diet alleviates the symptoms of osteoarthritis. Arthritis. 2015;2015:708152-708161. []
  6. Want to Lose Weight the Easy Way? []
  7. Can The UK Government Really Combat Child Obesity? []
  8. England’s Obesity Hotspots []
  9. Rheumatology – Oxford. 2018 May. What is the evidence for a role for diet and nutrition in osteoarthritis? Sally Thomas, Heather Browne, Ali Mobasheri, and Margaret P Rayman. []
  10. Monira Hussain S, Wang Y, Cicuttini FM. et al. Incidence of total knee and hip replacement for osteoarthritis in relation to the metabolic syndrome and its components: a prospective cohort study. Semin Arthritis Rheum 2014;43:429–36. []
  11. Visser AW, de Mutsert R, le Cessie S. et al. ; NEO Study Group. The relative contribution of mechanical stress and systemic processes in different types of osteoarthritis: the NEO study. Ann Rheum Dis 2015;74:1842–7. []
  12. Turmeric Curcumin & Osteoarthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM January 17th, 2014 Volume 16. []
  13. Ginger for Osteoarthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM December 5th, 2016 Volume 33 []
  14. Sesame Seeds for Knee Osteoarthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM November 7th, 2016 Volume 33 []
  15. Rose Hips for Osteoarthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM September 17th, 2010 Volume 4 []
  16. Phytomedicine. 2004 Nov;11(7-8):567-75. Soy protein may alleviate osteoarthritis symptoms. Arjmandi BH, Khalil DA, Lucas EA, Smith BJ, Sinichi N, Hodges SB, Juma S, Munson ME, Payton ME, Tivis RD, Svanborg A. []
  17. Antioxidant and antiarthritic potential of coriander (Coriandrum sativum L.) leaves. Article in e-SPEN Journal 7(6):e223–e228 · December 2012. []
  18. The Science on Açaí Berries. Written By Michael Greger M.D. FACLM on August 22nd, 2013 []
  19. Benefits of Cabbage Leaves on the Knee for Osteoarthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM June 18th, 2018 Volume 42 []
  20. C.-L. Shen, B. J. Smith, D.-F. Lo, M.-C. Chyu, D. M. Dunn, C.-H. Chen, I.-S. Kwun. Dietary polyphenols and mechanisms of osteoarthritis. J. Nutr. Biochem. 2012 23(11):1367 – 137. []
  21. Wikipedia: Epigallocatechin gallate []
  22. Wikipedia: Resveratrol []
  23. Wikipedia: Nobiletin []
  24. Wikipedia: Genistein []
  25. Hänninen, Kaartinen K, Rauma AL, et al. Antioxidants in vegan diet and rheu-matic disorders. Toxicology. 2000;155:45-53 []
  26. Hafström I, Ringertz B, Spångberg A, et al. A vegan diet free of gluten im-proves the signs and symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis: the effects on arthritis correlate with a reduction in antibodies to food antigens. Rheumatology (Ox-ford). 2001;40:1175-1179. []
  27. Müller H, de Toledo FW, Resch KL. Fasting followed by vegetarian diet in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: a systematic review. Scand J Rheumatol.2001;30:1-10. []
  28. McDougall J, Bruce B, Spiller G, Westerdahl J, McDougall M. Effects of a very low-fat, vegan diet in subjects with rheumatoid arthritis. J Altern Complement Med. 2002;8:71-75. []
  29. Turmeric Curcumin & Rheumatoid Arthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM January 15th, 2014 Volume 16 []
  30. J Med Food. 2016 Aug;19(8). Efficacy of Turmeric Extracts and Curcumin for Alleviating the Symptoms of Joint Arthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials. Daily JW, Yang M, Park S. []
  31. Aust Fam Physician. 2012 Jul;41(7):495-8. Rosehip – an evidence based herbal medicine for inflammation and arthritis. Cohen M. []
  32. Toxicol Ind Health. 2014 Sep;30(8):738-49. Nutraceuticals of anti-inflammatory activity as complementary therapy for rheumatoid arthritis. Al-Okbi SY []
  33. Adv Biomed Res. 2014; 3: 100. Potent health effects of pomegranate. Aida Zarfeshany, Sedigheh Asgary, Shaghayegh Haghjoo Javanmard. []
  34. PharmaNutrition. 2016 Jul;4(3):123-131. Epub 2016 Jun 4. Anti-Inflammatory Effects of the Essential Oils of Ginger (Zingiber officinale Roscoe) in Experimental Rheumatoid Arthritis. Funk JL, Frye JB, Oyarzo JN, Chen J, Zhang H, Timmermann BN. []
  35. Rheumatoid Arthritis. Regulation of Transforming Growth Factor β–Activated Kinase Activation by Epigallocatechin‐3‐Gallate in Rheumatoid Arthritis Synovial Fibroblasts: Suppression of K63‐Linked Autoubiquitination of Tumor Necrosis Factor Receptor–Associated Factor 6. Anil K. Singh Sadiq Umar Sharayah Riegsecker Mukesh Chourasia Salahuddin Ahmed. First published: 16 October 2015. []
  36. Int J Mol Sci. 2016 Jun 9;17(6). Flavonoids as Cytokine Modulators: A Possible Therapy for Inflammation-Related Diseases. Leyva-López N, Gutierrez-Grijalva EP, Ambriz-Perez DL, Heredia JB. []
  37. Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis. 2013 Apr; 5(2): 77–94. Role of inflammation in the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis: latest findings and interpretations. Jeremy Sokolovecorresponding, Christin M. Lepus. []
  38. Arthritis. Volume 2015, Article ID 708152, 9 pages. Clinical Study. Whole-Foods, Plant-Based Diet Alleviates the Symptoms of Osteoarthritis. Chelsea M. Clinton, Shanley O’Brien, Junwen Law, Colleen M. Renier, and Mary R. Wendt. []
  39. Healthy Joints: Dr Greger []
  40. Preventing Arthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM September 16th, 2008 Volume 2. []
  41. A. Hailu, S.F. Knutsen, & G.E. Fraser. Associations between meat consumption and the prevalence of degenerative arthritis and soft tissue disorders in the Adventist health study, California U.S.A. J Nutr Health Aging, 10(1):7-14, 2006. []
  42. Diet & Rheumatoid Arthritis. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM September 20th, 2010 Volume 4 []
  43. PCRM: Focus on plant-based foods to ease arthritis pain. []
  44. Which Athlete Ate the Most Nitrates… []
  45. Nutritionfacts.org: Nitrates []
  46. CNS: Nitric Oxide & Dietary Nitrate: Another Reason to Eat Your Vegetables []
  47. Front Pharmacol. 2013; 4: 71. The effects of cocoa on the immune system. Francisco J. Pérez-Cano, Malen Massot-Cladera, Àngels Franch, Cristina Castellote, and Margarida Castell. []
  48. Nutrients. 2016 Jun; 8(6): 321. Impact of Cocoa Consumption on Inflammation Processes—A Critical Review of Randomized Controlled Trials. Sabine Ellinger, Peter Stehle. []
  49. Clin Rheumatol. 2016; 35(12): 2901–2908. Dietary intake and risk of rheumatoid arthritis—a cross section multicenter study. Jing He, et al. []
  50. Front Nutr. 2017; 4: 52. Managing Rheumatoid Arthritis with Dietary Interventions. Shweta Khanna, Kumar Sagar Jaiswal, Bhawna Gupta. []
  51. What is the evidence for a role for diet and nutrition in osteoarthritis?Sally Thomas Heather Browne Ali Mobasheri Margaret P Rayman. Rheumatology, Volume 57, Issue suppl_4, 1 May 2018, Pages iv61–iv74. []
  52. Arthritis Research UK: Are there any links between tomatoes and worsening arthritis? []
  53. ScienceDaily: Garlic could protect against hip osteoarthritis. December 16, 2010. King’s College London. []
  54. Friday, January 29. Arthritis Today Magazine. Research Shows Apples Can Cut Cholesterol and Inflammation []
  55. Vitamin C Supplements vs An Apple []
  56. Arthritis Research UK: Has eating bananas helped with my arthritis pain? []
  57. Athletic Performance & Physical Damage on Plant-Based Diets []
  58. WFPB Eating to Prevent Sports Injuries []
  59. Exercise vs Whole Food Plant-Based Diet []
  60. Good Bacteria Produce Butyrate []
  61. Gout, Uric Acid, Urea, Purines & Plant-Based Diets []
  62. Wholism vs Reductionism – Not Just a War of Words [] []
  63. Campbell, T. Colin. Whole: Rethinking the Science of Nutrition (p. 97). BenBella Books, Inc.. Kindle Edition. []

Say Cheese?

You may not have noticed that there’s a section in www.wholefoodplantbaseddiet.com which is full of really fascinating and informative podcasts. Why not have a scroll through them?

They’re great for listening to while you’re doing other things – cooking wonderful plant-based meals, for instance…

I’ve just added another podcast released by the gorgeous Dr Greger, entitled “Say Cheese?

In this 13 minute long animated rant against the almost unbelievable tricks of major food industries, he explains how they can produce spurious studies to support the nutritional value of…you guessed it… their own products.

For instance, he explains how the US National Dairy Council were able to produce a shocking study which claims they have demonstrated that cheese causes less inflammation than a vegan alternative. But how did they manage such a trick? Click on the link below to find out.

Breakfast Confusion

An article in the Telegraph 1 makes the choice clear about whether or not breakfast is the most important meal of the day – well, as clear as mud

The study

The article reports on a recent BMJ study 2 which demonstrates that the accepted ‘truth’ about the primary importance of breakfast is not quite as true as we’ve been told.

Specifically, the study (a systematic review and meta-analysis) reviewed 13 previous breakfast studies and found that those who eat breakfast consume significantly more calories (an average of around 249 kcal a day) than those who skip the meal – and then end up weighing more.

A little more on this study below, but first: why have we been told that breakfast is so important?

Confused? Just you wait…

Breakfast is BAD

For decades, health experts have warned us not to miss breakfast if we want to lose/maintain a healthy weight, since we’ll just end up snacking more later in the day.

Breakfast is GOOD

But the newspaper points out that previous studies suggested eating breakfast “fires up the metabolism and can help dieters stop overeating later in the day.

Breakfast is BAD

Then the newspaper points out that the BMJ suggests otherwise, since it “…found those who skip breakfast do not compensate by eating more later in the day.

Breakfast is GOOD

The NHS advice goes like this: “Some people skip breakfast because they think it will help them lose weight. In fact, research shows that people who regularly eat breakfast are less likely to be overweight.3 .

Breakfast is GBOAODD

Then the Telegraph tries to clarify the situation for us by stating that “researchers also found no significant difference in metabolic rates between breakfast eaters and skippers – suggesting there is no evidence that eating breakfast may help with weight loss due to “efficient” burning of calories earlier in the day.

Study Conclusion

Surely this meta-analysis will clear up the situation for us…mmm.

The researchers’ conclusion includes the following decisive statement: “Caution is needed when recommending breakfast for weight loss in adults, as it could have the opposite effect.”

A Bit of History

So, if there’s so little clarity on whether or not we should have breakfast, why has there been such a widespread belief passed down to us that breakfast is the most important meal of the day?

Breakfast Cereal As A Passion Killer

As far back as 1895, John Harvey Kellogg created Kellogg’s Corn Flakes and advertised it as a health food which, as part of a bland diet, would not only counter ill-health, but would minimise sexual arousal. Since then, Kellogg’s have advertised how healthy their cereals are, irrespective of a lack of positive evidence and a fair amount of evidence to the contrary 4 – especially nowadays, with the shocking amounts of added sugar in most breakfast cereals which the manufacturers still want to make us think are a healthy option.

The Classic Bacon Breakfast

The bacon industry were having a bit of a recession during the 1920’s in the United States; so they used the services of public relations supremo Edward Bernays (a nephew of Sigmund Freud).

Did they get him to publicise some wonderful new research that showed the healthful benefits of a good bacon-based morning fry up? Not quite! Rather, they got him to persuade around 5,000 US doctors to sign a statement that supported the importance of starting the day with a big breakfast.

This message was spread across the country as though it was solid fact, although it was based on an utter lack of any supporting scientific evidence.

If General Foods Say It, It Must Be true

In 1944, General Foods (makers of breakfast cereals) came up with the phrase “breakfast is the most important meal of the day”.

During the GF campaign, radio advertisements announced “Nutrition experts say breakfast is the most important meal of the day.”

Reminds me of doctors who used to claim that their favourite brand of cigarettes were actually good for you – and it was probably just a coincidence that they were getting sponsored (and given free boxes of ciggies) by the cigarette companies.

Kings, Princes & Paupers

In 1954, nutritionist Adelle Davis came up with the phrase: “Eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince, and dinner like a pauper.” Whilst there was no solid evidence for or against the validity of this bold claim, it didn’t stop the phrase from becoming de rigueur until the present day.

Eggsaggerating The Importance of Breakfast

Tim Spector, professor of genetic epidemiology at King’s College London, thinks that most of us alive today have been indoctrinated from childhood by campaigns like “go to work on an egg”.

But who could possibly benefit from such advice if it doesn’t have any proven nutritional validity? Fay Weldon came up with the classic slogan “Go to work on an egg” in 1957 at the request of the UK’s Egg Marketing Board, reinforced in the 1960’s by TV adverts with the comedian Tony Hancock.

It’s Just a Matter of Numbers

Public Health England had a 2018 campaign on healthy eating 5 . In this campaign they urged us to follow a simple rule of thumb:

  • breakfast – 400 calories
  • lunch – 600 calories
  • dinner – 600 calories

Great! Sorted! Oh, but maybe they haven’t heard that calorie counting has been shown as a non-starter for sustained and healthy weight loss/maintenance 6 … And perhaps it would be useful to point out that 400 calories of doughnuts is not quite the same as 400 calories of unprocessed fruit and veg.

News – What News?

Oh and by the way, the Daily Telegraph and other media outlets made such a big fuss about this story, in spite of a short sentence in the cited study which goes something like this: “All of the included trials were at high or unclear risk of bias in at least one domain and had only short term follow-ups…. As the quality of the included studies was mostly low, the findings should be interpreted with caution.

This is a fact that the Telegraph article didn’t mention. This begs the question whether this study was even newsworthy. The only effect it probably had on the general public was to sow confusion with an eye-catching headline.

Final thoughts

It’s important to to note that the BMJ study (undertaken by researchers from Monash University in Melbourne, Australia) were looking at 13 randomised controlled trials related to breakfast and weight in high income countries, including the UK. This is probably key to the confusion.

The breakfasts eaten in these ‘high income countries’ are likely to be the type of breakfasts that cause the confusion – bacon and eggs, breads and pastries, porridge and cow’s milk, breakfast cereals from the likes of Kellogg’s and Nestlé, etc.

If optimally healthy WFPB breakfasts 7 were eaten, I suspect the results would be somewhat different. Not that it would give a clear indication of whether it was better to eat or not to eat breakfast, since it may well be that very little change would be detected in the weight of the WFPB eaters.

Why not?

In my experience, and it’s just that so far, eating a WFPB diet (whether or not it regularly includes breakfast) results in the body reaching its optimal healthy weight and, if you eat when your body ‘tells’ you, then it doesn’t seem to matter when or what you eat – so long as the foods come from wholefood plants without any added salt, oil or sugar.

And, finally, I’m not against breakfasts; in fact, I eat a huge breakfast of berries, seeds, nuts, fruit, and whole grains. It’s just that this is another case of the media (and hence the unsuspecting reader/viewer) focusing on minutiae at the cost of the wider picture.

It’s the food! The type of food, not whether you’re dieting this way or that, eating the right amount of calories, tucking into or skipping your breakfasts: it’s whether the food you put into your mouth is the type that offers optimal human health and longevity, or if it enslaves your taste buds, poisons and bloats your body, and does so without you ever seriously questioning the motives of those who peddle their cheap junk, and without these companies giving a damn about whether your health is seriously and irrevocably compromised – so long as they make their profits.

 


References

  1. Daily Telegraph 31 January 2019: Breakfast may not be the most important meal of the day, after all. []
  2. Effect of breakfast on weight and energy intake: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ 2019; 364 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l42. []
  3. NHS: Eight Tips For Healthy Eating. []
  4. Guardian 23 November 2010: Drop that spoon! The truth about breakfast cereals []
  5. Public Health England: 2018 Healthy Eating Campaign []
  6. The Case Against Counting Calories []
  7. WFPB Breakfast Recipes. []

Eat to Live or Live to Eat?

Has it ever occurred to you just how central taste is when it comes to food? Indeed, it’s so important that it tends to eclipse every other element involved in food preparation and dining. However, could it be that our preoccupation with flavour and texture has played a major role in the current tsunami of non-communicable, diet-related diseases?

Food Critics’ 7 Rules

A journalist and food critic called Roberta Schira claims 1 there are 7 rules you must use to make sure you are experiencing good food when you dine out:

  1. Ingredients – Must be the best the market can offer, fresh and of quality
  2. Technique – Manipulate and transform ingredients in a dish to respect its essence, tradition and science
  3. Genius – The capacity to transform something that already exists into something new
  4. Equilibrium/Harmony – A sense of harmony within oneself and the world during the culinary experience
  5. Atmosphere – The ensemble of details that makes one utter “I feel good here”
  6. Project – Something that goes beyond taste, price, calories. You can’t tell the story of food through numbers
  7. Value – Did I get my money’s worth at this dinner? Good service, attention to detail, good feeling and thoughts?

What Does A Food Critic Do?

One career’s advice website 2 describes the role of a food/restaurant critic:

A food critic …encapsulates the dining experience and relays that experience to readers, viewers or listeners. This may include descriptions of the food, whether it tastes good, the serving size, the ambiance of the restaurant, the price, and how well the service staff do their job.

What Qualifications Does A Food Critic Need?

According to myjobsearch.com3 : “There are no formal academic qualifications which are required to perform this job…a good understanding of creative writing and language expression is essential in supplying exciting copy.

What’s The Best Meal?

According to an article by Jay Rayner in the Guardian 4 , some of the best meals he’d ever eaten were:

  • gnocchi made from jellified egg yolk
  • ham consommé bobbing with cubes of melon
  • suckling pig at Fergus Henderson’s St John
  • crème brûlée
  • freshly boiled crab with a loaf of crusty bread and a pot of Hellmann’s mayonnaise

While his all-time best meal being:

  • a two-inch thick rib-eye steak, crisp, rustling homemade chips and a good bottle of Bordeaux

Britain’s Top 50 Gastropubs 2019

A Daily Telegraph article 5 looked at the following ‘taste-packed’ offerings in the 50 named gastropubs:

  • a “treasure trove” of seafood in pastry with lobster sauce
  • saddleback pork shoulder, fennel risotto and apple
  • chicken liver pâté with cornichons and toast
  • pan roasted wood pigeon, bulgur wheat, kale and tropea onion or roast grouse in Armagnac gravy
  • venison bonbons: four neat little ping-pong balls served with a mustard dip
  • Scotch eggs, pork pies and charcuterie
  • smoked eel with lovage and pickled onions, halibut with spatzle and rhubarb cobbler with popcorn ice cream
  • Goosnargh chickens and slow-braised lambs
  • devilled crab, salmon and shrimp pâté with sea salt croûtes
  • aromatic tuna, Asian shredded salad with soy and citrus dressing and a superb Goan monkfish
  • prawn curry with coconut rice and grilled flat bread
  • Gunton venison stew with herb baked dumplings
  • smoked haddock chowder
  • oxtail, beef skirt and real ale suet pudding
  • parfait of Cotswold chicken livers
  • braised venison suet pudding, potato puree, seared foie gras, red wine sauce
  • St Margaret’s Farm free-range pork belly with crackling, black pudding
  • Mrs Kirkham’s Lancashire cheese souffle
  • Holkham Estate venison and Brancaster Mussels, washed down with Yetman’s beer and gin distilled with coastal botanicals
  • pot roast mallard, blood orange, celeriac gratin and watercress
  • sheep’s head broth
  • fish and chips
  • ham, egg and chips
  • baked potatoes
  • Provencal fish soup and gruyere followed by pot roast pheasant or confit duck leg
  • guinea fowl, pork and ham hock pie with mash and gravy
  • pork chop, caramelised apple, roasted hispi & black pudding
  • hake, new potatoes, cavil nero, caper, parsley butter
  • dry aged, grass-fed English and Scotch beef from an open grill
  • Chicksgrove beef and red wine macaronade with gremolata and buttered greens
  • dressed crab with a pint of prawns or baked St Marcellin, with toast and pickles
  • ox cheek, mushroom and ale in a suet crust
  • pork belly with malted onion and poached pear
  • loin of Cotswold venison with date purée
  • salt-baked parsnip and stilton, game and bacon pie
  • curried mutton
  • Jersey rock oysters with cabernet sauvignon and shallot dressing
  • sea bass, steak, risotto and burgers
  • brownies and sticky toffee puddings
  • venison and juniper suet pudding
  • goats cheese and beetroot tart with apple
  • hunch of venison with creamed spinach
  • terrines of pedigree Welsh pork, braised rabbit with deep fried polenta
  • house-cured goose ham, ewe’s curd, venison and hazelnut choux buns
  • Yorkshire Dales beef tartare with smoked bacon
  • steamed spice pineapple sponge with cinder toffee and rum-and-raisin ice cream
  • lobster, duck pie baked in brioche
  • 50-day-aged beef
  • crispy pig’s head with celeriac, green apple and watercress
  • venison chilli with red wine, chocolate and toasted rice cream

And the number one best gastropub 2019 offers:

  • slip sole with garlic butter
  • poached oysters with pickled cucumbers

Few, if any of the meals cited would stand up to close (or even distant) criticism in terms of the true impact such food has on the human body. Seen many thin and healthy-looking restaurant critics lately?

Is Organic, Free-Range & Locally-Sourced Enough?

These are, more or less, the only terms occasionally used within the whole review of the 50 gastropubs that are unconnected to the attractive taste of the food on offer. And it’s simply not enough that your beef or pork are organically reared in a neighbour’s pretty farm, or that the scallops and shrimps were caught by Freddie the Village Fisherman just this morning.

In previous blogs, we’ve covered so much research that proves beyond any reasonable doubt that consuming any animal or processed food – let alone that which has been drowned in extra virgin olive oil and served with organic whipped crème fraîche – is less than ideal for human health, especially when compared with a healthy and balanced plant-based diet.

Joe’s final thoughts

What’s revealing about the above, is the critic’s overarching emphasis on taste. The nutritional value of the food is either ignored totally or mentioned in part and in passing. It’s like going to the doctor to get advice on your cigarette-induced cough and only being given advice on what the doctor regards as the tastiest brand of cigarette, with no reference being made to what the fags are actually doing to your lungs and other organs. The main difference, at least to my mind, is that doctors no longer ignore the terrible side-effects of smoking like many of them once did (because most of them smoked!) while food critics continue as though there are no side-effects to the sort of food praised above.

If you stepped back for a moment and looked at this from a wider perspective, doesn’t it strike you as at least slightly odd that so little mention is ever made about whether or not the food that is so strongly advertised and promoted to us will make us ill? I mean, in a very real sense, we are what we eat.

Perhaps at some time in the future, people will look back as these decades with some surprise and disbelief that almost no emphasis was ever put on the micronutrients or even macronutrients essential to human health and well-being; that many of the most widely-known ‘experts’ on food required no training at all in nutrition, just years of training in how to tickle the taste bugs; that no links were made between what you put in your mouth and what it does to your body; with the primary emphasis always being on whether or not it tasted good.

But so what? Taste is important. And indeed it is. But is it really more important than physical and mental health?

We’ve become so focused on taste that we’ve become blind to our tortured, malnourished, bloated bodies – the greasy blocked arteries, bulging fat, creeping disease and, all too often, early and unnecessary death.

So does this mean that eating a plant-based diet is tasteless in comparison with eating the typical animal-based, fatty, sugary fare? Well, if you want to be so addicted to a food that you simply can’t stop eating, even when you know you’ve had enough, or if you want to feel yourself compelled to stuff certain foods into your body, even when you know they’re going to make you feel horrid and are destined to pile on the pounds, then put taste at the top of your dietary priorities – because whole plant-foods will certainly not be so addictive that you’ll be compelled to eat beyond the point at which your body is genuinely satisfied, and, in any case, it would be highly unlikely that you could do any harm to yourself by overeating whole plant-foods.

Other species eat food in order to survive. They eat when they’re hungry and, unless humans are feeding them junk food, they will eat the ideal food to maintain their health – irrespective of whether it would be less tasty or addictive than a chocolate doughnut or a cheeseburger and chips.

Furthermore, starving humans and human populations who don’t have the ‘luxury’ of ever-available mountains of food like we do have little or no interest in the flavour of what they can eat. Their bodies tell them that they should simply get as much nutrient inside them as possible – no need to worry about adding a tasty sauce to it or covering it in spices, salt or sugar.

Finally, I’m not claiming that we should ignore the taste of food altogether in lieu of solely concentrating on its nutritional value; but I do suggest that when we feel compelled to eat a particular food (especially when we are quietly aware that it’s not an ideal food to eat for our health), we have fallen victim to the easy-availability and widespread acceptance of foods that cater to those few thousand taste buds on the top of our tongue.

We’ve become unwittingly enmeshed in the misguided trap that our society itself has fallen into – seeking the buzz of fleeting oral gratification at the expense of the most precious possession we each own – our own bodies.


References

  1. DID YOU EAT WELL? 7 RULES TO IDENTIFY GOOD CUISINE []
  2. Sokanu.com: What Does A Food Critic Do? []
  3. myjobsearch.com: Food Critics Jobs []
  4. What’s the best meal I’ve ever eaten? []
  5. Telegraph 28 January 2019: Britain’s top 50 gastropubs 2019, revealed. []

Plant-Based Mistakes

Whilst I’d maintain that the biggest dietary mistake we can make is to continue eating animals rather than plants, there are some pretty serious blunders that can be made by those who eat nothing but plant foods. This may especially be the case if you regard yourself as a vegan rather than a WFPBer (if such a word exists!) and don’t place your own and your family’s own health above or, at least, equal to the other reasons that you define yourself as a vegan.

A Specifically Vegan Mistake?

If vegans are only going plant-based because of concerns about animal rights and/or the environment, without considering the nutritional value of their own new diet, they usually end up eating highly-refined carbohydrates – pasta, bagels, bread, commercially-prepared ready-meals etc – and not a balanced wholefood diet.

As we’ve discussed previously 1 , replacing meat with refined carbs is not the way to get optimal health benefits and some suggest that you may as well eat animals if your diet is largely processed junk and lacks the green stuff.

A General Plant-Eater’s Mistake #1?

A mistake that all plant-eaters can make is to ignore nutritional priorities. That is, to think that simply by eating a balanced plant-based diet (even if it’s completely wholefood with no added sugar, oils and salt) you’re destined to get all the nutrients your body needs to avoid potentially dangerous health conditions. The nutrients generally considered of particular concern for plant-eaters include:

  • protein
  • iron
  • zinc
  • calcium
  • iodine, and
  • vitamin D

I don’t have much time for worrying about the first four items. Without eating animals, legumes alone provide a rich form of protein, iron and zinc, and green vegetables (some say an emphasis should be on low-oxalate 2 green veg) are an excellent source of calcium, along with some nuts and seeds.

However, iodine and, especially, vitamin D are not to be ignored. You can’t get the former from plants and getting the appropriate amount (not too much and not too little) of the latter can be something of a minefield, as we saw in previous blogs 3 4 . So, what’s to be done?

Well, regarding iodine, you can take a supplement and/or eat appropriate amounts of those foods (e.g. wakame) that are considered reasonably okay in moderation.

Regarding vitamin D, whether or not you eat fortified foods on a plant-based diet, this absolutely essential vitamin can become a real problem if, of course, you don’t get lots and lots of good, warm sunlight exposure on a regular basis. We looked at vitamin D in previous blogs 5 6 , and ignoring its importance is not to be advised, although enough people (plant-eaters and omnivores) are known to do so at their peril 7 .

Below, I’ll mention a potentially good supplemented source of iodine and vitamin D.

A General Plant-Eater’s Mistake #2?

Whilst I could have covered this one in the above list, it always seems like one nutrient that deserves special mention –vitamin B12.

B12 is a potentially big problem for vegans and, for that matter, even for someone eating the optimum WFPB diet if, that is, they don’t supplement B12. Whilst B12 is made by microorganisms, and we have billions of these living inside us, those that make B12 in our bodies happen to be low down in the large intestine. So, unless we eat our own poo (not to be recommended – do I even need to remind you of that?!), the B12 we produce is either absorbed by bacteria within our lower intestine or discharged as faeces.

Interestingly, at least one research study 8 found that some people who eat negligible amounts of dairy and meat (in this particular study, rural Iranians), had quite high B12 levels (~411 pg/ml average), with no apparent cases of megaloblastic or pernicious anaemia – both of which are just two of the results of B12 deficiency. It was thought that these Iranians’ low-protein diets encouraged B12-producing bacteria to rise up from the colon (large intestine) to the ileum (the lower part of the small intestine) where the body can effectively absorb the B12 for its own use. This is still an area of uncertainty, since it may be that they picked up sufficient B12 through contamination, being that they lived among their animals and the faeces the animals produced.

Which Plants Provide B12?

There are some plant foods that are known to provide some B12 – such as sea plants (e.g. wakame), blue-green algae, yeasts (e.g. brewer’s yeast), and fermented plant foods (e.g. miso, tempeh or tofu) – but they are not a reliable source . Getting B12 from these rather than a daily B12 supplement is NOT recommended by me or by the likes of Dr Greger, Dr T Colin Campbell, Dr John McDougall et al.

Variation. Variation.

Apart from anything else, you can’t be sure about the amount of B12 in any single food product. For instance, tempeh produced in wooden barrels in Indonesia is reported 9 10 to have some B12 that can be absorbed by our bodies, but when it’s produced in very clean stainless steel vats (as in the US), the resulting tempeh is unlikely to contain much if any B12.

Active vs Inactive B12

Another complicating factor with B12 is whether or not it’s the active or inactive form 11 12 of cobalamin (the general term used for different forms of B12) .

The latter, inactive forms, can bind to the B12 receptors in our bodies and effectively block much of any active B12 from finding an available receptor, with the result that B12 is not absorbed efficiently by the body – leading to a functional B12 deficiency.

So, for instance, when you dry seaweed, some of the active B12 is turned into the inactive form. Another example is chlorella (a type of green algae): whilst this is regarded by some as a useful source of B12, there’s simply not enough evidence yet to prove that this can be used as a sole source of B12 for plant-eaters who don’t use B12 supplements or eat B12 fortified foods.

Playing Russian roulette with the permanent damage that can result from chronic B12 deficiency is not a sensible option.

Although it’s increasingly clear 13 14 that there’s a worryingly high level of B12 insufficiency and even deficiency within the general population, and the Institute of Medicine in the US recommends 15 that everyone over the age of 50* shouldn’t rely on animal foods alone for B12, it’s generally considered 16 that the likelihood of finding B12 deficiency in different dietary groups is as follows (from least likely to most likely):

  • omnivores
  • lacto-ovo vegetarians
  • vegetarians
  • vegans
  • raw vegans

Over 50’s & B12 Deficiency

* When you eat animals, the B12 is physically bound to the animal protein; however, in order to cleave off the B12 from the protein, you need to be producing enough stomach acid and enzymes so you can absorb the B12 into your bloodstream. The problem is that it’s estimated 17 that up to 30% of people aged over 50 don’t produce enough, and so even eating lots of animals doesn’t guarantee healthy B12 levels as we age. And this is important stuff for all of us, since dementia is known 18 to be one of the results of B12 deficiency.

Mothers, Babies, Infants & B12 Deficiency

Of course, at the other end of the age groups, as we’ve discussed in considerable detail 19 pregnant women and infants also need to be really careful about B12 levels, since deficiency can result in irreversible brain damage in the baby 20 and serious health conditions in infants 21 . As pointed out in a previous blog 22 , it’s really important for potential mothers to be informed about the real dangers for their babies if they (the mothers) don’t get the balance right between folic acid (vitamin B9) and vitamin B12 .

They Missed Out WFPB!

You may have noticed that WFPB was not in the above list (from omnivore down to raw vegan). Well, if you’re eating a WFPB diet, you may find that fortified foods are not very common in your diet – indeed, when you make your own plant milks (or choose non-fortified versions), make your own bread (or even your own flour), and avoid commercially-produced breakfast cereals, read-meals, tinned beans, etc etc, you may be eating no fortified foods at all. And, in any case, the amount of fortification of many vitamins within fortified foods is likely to be far below your daily requirements. I guess this means that some WFPBers can be at a similarly high risk of potential deficiencies as raw vegans if, that is, they don’t take appropriate measures.

B12 Supplementation & WFPB Diet

So, when eating a WFPB diet, it’s time to look very seriously at supplementation as being probably the most reliable and sensible route. As I’ve mentioned in some detail previously 23 , one option is the Vegan Society’s Veg-1 supplement which some authorities would and some would not regard as containing sufficient B12. Of course, there are other mixed supplements and single B12 supplements available. My personal approach, at the moment, based on my research, is to take Veg-1 for its iodine and vitamin D content as well as a separate 1000 mcg/μg 24 B12 supplement at least twice a week if it’s cyanocobalamin or daily if it’s methylcobalamin 25 .

Difference Between Different Types of B12 Supplements

Vitamin B12 supplements are usually derived from two sources: methylcobalamin or cyanocobalamin.

Chemically, these are almost identical, with each containing a cobalt ion with a surrounding corrin ring – so called because it’s the ‘core’ of the B12 cobalamin. The cobalt ion has a methyl group stuck to the cobalt ion, while the the cyanocobalamin has a cyanide molecule (don’t worry, it’s not poison in this form!) – hence the names of each.

Cyanocobalamin is a more stable synthetic form 26 of B12 not found in nature, and is used more often in supplements: it’s also cheaper to manufacture. It gets converted into either methylcobalamin or adenosylcobalamin when it enters the body.

In humans, methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin (not used so much in supplements) are the two active forms of B12 27 . Methylcobalamin is in supplements and can also be found in animal foods, although not in predictable quantities, of course.

Final thoughts

You have to have been living under a stone not to know by now that there’s tons of solid evidence that a healthy and balanced plant-based diet beats the pants off an animal-based diet if, that is, you want optimal health and don’t just want to give in to the addictive taste temptation of meaty/fatty/salty food that so many consider the be all and end all of what human nutrition is all about.

Therefore, so long as you’re careful to take into account the importance of the above nutrients (as well as take appropriate steps to prevent any deficiencies), you can dive into your G-BOMBS 28 or your Daily Dozen 29 with gay abandon.

Finally, and before leaving the Big B12 issue, it’s really worth bearing in mind that, to some extent, we’re straining at a gnat 30 here, by acting as if eating a healthy plant-based diet can generally be a worry compared with eating the usual animal-heavy, processed Western (SAD) diet. I’ll let Dr Greger see us out on this note 31 : “Make no mistake: vitamin B12 is important. But so is keeping our perspective, given the millions who are crippled and die from the onslaught of chronic disease that could be prevented, stopped, and reversed with a B12-fortified, plant-based diet.


References

  1. Greggs’ Vegan Sausage Rolls – Why Veganism Can Fail []
  2. Vegans & Calcium []
  3. Iodine Deficiency in Vegans []
  4. Vegans and Iodine []
  5. Shining A Light on Vitamin D []
  6. Vitamin D & Vegans []
  7. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. Author manuscript. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. 2014 Oct; 144PA: 138–145. Is vitamin D deficiency a major global public health problem? Cristina Palacios and Lilliana Gonzalez. []
  8. Halsted JA, Carroll J, Dehghani A, Loghmani M, Prasad A. Serum vitamin B12 concentration in dietary deficiency. Am J Clin Nutr. 1960 May-Jun;8:374-6. []
  9. LWT. Volume 96, October 2018, Pages 513-518. Enhancing vitamin B12 in lupin tempeh by in situ fortification. Judith C.M.Wolkers-Rooijackers, Martha F.Endika, Eddy J.Smid. []
  10. Production of vitamin B-12 in tempeh, a fermented soybean food Article in Applied and Environmental Microbiology 34(6):773-6 January 1978. []
  11. Active B12 testing []
  12. Vitamin B12 deficiency. BMJ 2014; 349. 4 September 2014. []
  13. Science Daily: Genetic Variants Associated With Vitamin B12. September 9, 2008. Harvard School of Public Health []
  14. How common is vitamin B-12 deficiency? | The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. LH Allen – ‎2008. []
  15. Harvard Medical School: Getting Enough Vitamin B12? April, 2015. Linda Antinoro, R.D., L.D.N., J.D., C.D.E. []
  16. What Are The Biggest Mistakes Vegans Make? by Brenda Davis []
  17. Cognitive Vitality: GUT CHECK: ARE YOU GETTING ENOUGH B12? September 16, 2016 Yuko Hara, PhD []
  18. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol. 2005 Mar;18(1):33-8. Neuropsychology of vitamin B12 deficiency in elderly dementia patients and control subjects. Osimani A1, Berger A, Friedman J, Porat-Katz BS, Abarbanel JM. []
  19. Vegan Pregnancy & Parenting []
  20. WebMD: Birth Defects Linked to Low Vitamin B12. By Jennifer Warner. []
  21. Med J Aust. 1979 Jul 14;2(1):1-3. Brain damage in infancy and dietary vitamin B12 deficiency. Wighton MC, Manson JI, Speed I, Robertson E, Chapman E. []
  22. B12 Supplements Are Efficient But Caution With Folic Acid []
  23. Vegan Society Veg-1: Does It Contain Enough B12? []
  24. Microgram terminology. []
  25. Brenda Davis’ Comments on cyanocobalamin and methylcobalamin []
  26. BMJ. Clinical Review. Vitamin B12 deficiency. []
  27. NIH: Vitamin B12 []
  28. Health = Nutrient Intake ÷ Calories []
  29. Dr. Greger’s Daily Dozen Checklist. Michael Greger M.D. FACLM September 11th, 2017 Volume 38 []
  30. Meaning of the phrase “straining at a gnat?” The phrase comes from the words of Jesus, as recorded in the Gospel of Matthew. … He follows this up in verse 24 with the phrase you asked about: “Ye blind guides, which strain at a gnat, and swallow a camel.” []
  31. Vegan B12 deficiency: putting it into perspective. Written By Michael Greger M.D. FACLM on August 25th, 2011 []

Evidence-Based Eating Guide by Dr Greger

If you haven’t already come across Dr Michael Greger and his invaluable website, nutritionfacts.org 1 , then you’re in for a treat. And, even if you have spent many happy hours listening to his dulcet tones 2 , or reading his fact-based articles 3 and his excellent books 4 5 , there’s a free WFPB dietary guide called the Evidence-Based Eating Guide 6 that you can download for yourself and/or for others who you think might benefit from it. (You will need to subscribe to Dr Greger’s FREE newsletter to get the guide, though – something that’s well worth doing in any case – link to relevant page.)

The Guide contains the following:

  • Why Nutrition Matters
  • Dining by Traffic Light (red, amber and green – never eat, eat sparingly, eat as much as you want, respectively)
  • Dr Greger’s Daily Dozen (the 12 foods that he recommends we eat every day – downloadable as a free app)
  • Tips For Including the Daily Dozen
  • Sample Menus for Checking Off the Daily Dozen
  • Nutritional Consideration & Common Nutritional Concerns
  • Put It Into Action

You won’t do better than following Dr Greger’s advice if you want to benefit from a WFPB diet.

Everything he claims about nutrition is backed up with solid evidence from peer-reviewed studies that you can check out yourself.

There are few medical experts in the field of nutrition who can match Dr Greger’s prolific output of articles and videos, all supported by facts-based research . He’s an inspiration to thousands and one of my personal heroes – he’s also hilariously entertaining.

If you want to introduce anyone to videos, articles or literature on WFPB diets, he’d be a perfect entree for them.

Enjoy!


References

  1. Nutritionfacts.org – Dr Greger’s non-commercial, fact-based WFPB website []
  2. Must-see Dr Greger video: How Not To Die: The Role of Diet in Preventing, Arresting, and Reversing Our Top 15 Killers []
  3. Introducing the Evidence-Based Eating Guide article. []
  4. How Not to Die: Discover the foods scientifically proven to prevent and reverse disease by Dr Greger []
  5. The How Not To Die Cookbook: Over 100 Recipes to Help Prevent and Reverse Disease by Dr Greger []
  6. Evidence-Based Eating Guide by Dr Michael Greger []

Must-See Plant-Based Films

I’ve already mentioned a number of influential films which introduce WFPB diets for human health as well as veganism, where the emphasis is also strongly on animal welfare and environmental protection. Such films as Forks Over Knives, Cowspiracy, and What The Health. However, there are a number of other films that I would recommend you take a look at and, if you are so inclined, introduce to your family and friends.

H.O.P.E – What You Eat Matters

HOPE – What You Eat Matters is a life-changing documentary uncovering and revealing the effects of our typical Western diet on our health, the environment and animals. Featuring Jane Goodall, T. Colin Campbell, Caldwell B. Esselstyn, Vandana Shiva, Melanie Joy and many other experts. Available for free on YouTube:

Let Us Be Heroes – The true Cost of Our Food Choices

How much difference can one person make? Let Us Be Heroes explores the impact of our food and lifestyle choices on our health, our home planet and our values by sharing inspiring stories from athletes, food and fashion entrepreneurs, a public speaker and an ocean warrior fighting to protect people, planet and animals. Available for free on YouTube:

Vegan 2017 – The Film

Covers the ever growing vegan movement and how it’s best for the animals, human health, and the planet. Available for free on YouTube:

Vegan 2018 – The Film

Following on from the 2017 film, Vegan 2018 – The Film sees a movement in its ascendancy, showing how more people are starting to move away from the ethical, environmental, and health horrors of animal exploitation. A number of celebrities including Lewis Hamilton and Moby share their views. Available for free on YouTube:

Running For Good – The Fiona Oakes Documentary

From the director of Cowspiracy and What The Health, Keegan Kuhn, this sports documentary is narrated by Rich Roll and follows world record marathon runner Fiona Oakes in her attempt not only to set a new global record in endurance racing, but to compete in the “toughest footrace on earth,” the Marathon Des Sables, a 250km race through the Sahara Desert in an aim to raise the plight of animals. A fascinating interview with Fiona and Keegan Kuhn by Rich Roll is available for free on YouTube, while the film itself can be rented (downloaded) for £3.01:

Seaspiracy – What You Should Know About Fish & The Ocean

Seaspiracy is a short, eye-opening documentary created by The Friendly Activist. This 14 minute movie is packed full with data and facts about fishing and how the ingestion of fish is not only ruining our planet and its own oceans but is incredibly detrimental to our health. It also covers the forgotten victims, fish, are sentient beings who suffer from pain and stress when taken out of their natural environment. Available free on YouTube:

Dominion

Dominion uses drones, hidden and handheld cameras to expose the dark underbelly of modern animal agriculture, questioning the morality and validity of humankind’s dominion over the animal kingdom. While mainly focusing on animals used for food, it also explores other ways animals are exploited and abused by humans, including clothing, entertainment and research. Available for free at dominionmovement.com:

Final thoughts

Documentary films are a really powerful tool in our fight to help humans eat more healthily, and thereby avoid the horrid suffering and waste that diet-related diseases increasingly cause around the world. They also play a significant role in helping us to become aware of the true situation in relation to animal farming and the devastating environmental effects of our food choices.

Life-long dietary habits are perhaps one of the hardest things to change in one’s life; but without new information, what can we expect but that people will continue to consume what they’ve been brought up to regard as normal, acceptable, unquestioned.

Until new information is presented, there really can’t be any freedom of choice, and thus it’s hard to criticise people who simply don’t know any better. For me, it was watching Forks Over Knives that shattered the invisible screen that had prevented me from being aware of the realty of the harm caused by my own food choices – to me, to other animals and to the nature I would have claimed I already loved so much.

And since we all generally have a problem with being told what to do or having a sermon preached at us, being shown a well-produced documentary film is often the means by which the doors of perception are finally opened.

 


 

Vinegar Helps Prevent Type 2 Diabetes

Is there anything truly healthy about good old British fish and chips with plenty of salt and vinegar? Well, yes, there is – although it would probably come as something of a surprise to most people – it’s actually the vinegar (acetic acid). And what’s more, research shows that vinegar is able to help in the prevention of type 2 diabetes (T2D).

Vinegar study

A 2013 study 1 looked at how strategies to treat prediabetes and the slow progression to type 2 diabetes are urgently and increasingly needed. Their research indicated that by simply making one small dietary change, namely, adding vinegar to meals each day, it was possible to reduce fasting glucose significantly – something of great significance to prevent the risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

And its positive effect occurred within the first week of ‘treatment’ (just adding it to meals), and continued during the whole length of the 12-week study trial with no negative side-effects, unlike anti-diabetic pills.

Additionally, no other eating patterns need to be changed. That is, if you’re still going to eat unhealthily, just adding a tablespoon of vinegar twice a day to your meals will produce the positive effects.

Study design

The 19 healthy individuals selected for this 12 week trial were identified as being either pre-diabetic or as having a fasting blood glucose measure of >5.55 mmol/l at study entry.

They were split into two groups: one given a ‘vinegar pill‘ twice a day with meals, and the other given an apple cider vinegar drink with the two meals.

The apple cider drinks each contained a tablespoon (750 mg) of vinegar, whilst the vinegar pills (Apple Cider Vinegar tablets, General Nutrition Corporation, Pittsburgh, PA) contained only trace amounts of acetic acid (40 mg/tablet) – basically a placebo.

Study results

The average change in fasting glucose differed significantly between groups (0.91 ± 0.27 and 0.26 ± 0.17 mmol/l for the vinegar and control groups respectively). The results are shown in more detail in the charts below.

Study discussion

Previous studies 2 3 4 have suggested that the reasons that acetic acid, the defining ingredient of all vinegars, may have these positive effects is because it is able to:

  • interfere with carbohydrate digestion
  • promote glucose uptake by muscle
  • increase b-cell insulin secretion

This study showed that a single dietary strategy as simple as having regular vinegar (1 tablespoon at mealtime twice daily), can genuinely help in reducing fasting blood glucose concentrations. And, what’s more, this is demonstrably more effective that the standard pharmaceuticals, such as metformin 5 or rosiglitazone 6 . 7 8 . This positive effect of vinegar
is especially noteworthy when you consider the cost, access difficulties and toxicities associated pharmaceutical medications.

Study conclusion

This research adds to the growing literature demonstrating the antiglycaemic properties of vinegar. Purposeful integration of vinegar or acetic acid into the food matrix, beyond the standard dressings and sauces, may facilitate reductions in blood glucose concentrations in both those diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and those at risk for this disease.

Final thoughts

Whilst this is a small-scale study, its findings appear pretty convincing. And it’s not an isolated piece of research. It’s also backed up by other studies 9 10 11 12 13 . For instance, there’s a 2009 study 14 , once again over 12 weeks and with similar amounts of vinegar, but with 27 participants who already had T2D. This time, the researchers were looking at whether a daily ingestion of vinegar at mealtimes may favourably influence (i.e. reduce) HbA1c 15 values in these diabetic participants .

And the results? Indeed the vinegar consumption did reduce HbA1c when compared with the groups taking the placebo (a vinegar pill) and a pickled gherkin. The researchers concluded that the reduction in HbA1c was particularly impressive since the participants’ diabetic conditions were already being well controlled with medications.

And it appears as though it’s not simply a matter of slowing gastric emptying or even of preventing glucose from entering the blood stream 16 . Rather, the reason why vinegar leads to significantly less sugar staying in the blood is because it leaves the bloodstream faster (that is, gets into the cells quicker). This ability to enhance sugar disposal by lowering insulin resistance (the cause of type 2 diabetes), as well as improving the action of insulin in diabetics, is well supported by studies 17 18 .

Thus, the good news is that diabetics can tuck into potatoes – boiled, mashed or baked, so long as they add some vinegar.

Interestingly, when diabetics eat high-fibre meals, the glycaemic response appears 19 not to be affected much (if at all) by adding vinegar – probably because the fibre is already so good at preventing glycaemic spikes. The ideal foods to add vinegar to are high glycaemic index foods such as white potatoes and refined grains – not that the latter are to be recommended when compared with purple/sweet potatoes and whole grains, of course.

So, what’s stopping you? Any type of vinegar will do the trick – and we’ve listen a fair few previously 20 . Whether or not you’re overweight, think you’re prediabetic or actually have T2D already, this simple daily addition to your meals seems like a sensible move to keep insulin doing its job of getting that glucose into your cells.


References

  1. Journal of Functional Foods. Volume 5, Issue 4, October 2013, Pages 2007-2011. Vinegar ingestion at mealtime reduced fasting blood glucose concentrations in healthy adults at risk for type 2 diabetes. Carol S. Johnston. Samantha Quaglian. Serena White. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2013.08.003. []
  2. Ogawa, N., Satsu, H., Watanabe, H., Fukaya, M., Tsukamoto, Y., Miyamoto, Y., et al. (2000). Acetic acid suppresses the increase in disaccharidase activity that occurs during culture of caco-2 cells. Journal of Nutrition, 130, 507–513 []
  3. Fushimi, T., Tayama, K., Fukaya, M., Kitakoshi, K., Nakai, N., Tsukamoto, Y., et al. (2001). Acetic acid feeding enhances glycogen repletion in liver and skeletal muscle of rats. Journal of Nutrition, 131, 1973–1977. []
  4. Seok, H., Lee, J. Y., Park, E. M., Park, S. E., Lee, J. H., Lim, S., et al. (2012). Balsamic vinegar improves high fat-induced beta cell dysfunction via beta cell ABCA1. Diabetes & Metabolism Journal, 36, 275–279 []
  5. Metformin, marketed under the trade name Glucophage among others, is the first-line medication for the treatment of type 2 diabetes, particularly in people who are overweight. It is also used in the treatment of polycystic ovary syndrome. []
  6. Rosiglitazone (trade name Avandia) is an antidiabetic drug in the thiazolidinedione class. It works as an insulin sensitizer, by binding to the PPAR in fat cells and making the cells more responsive to insulin. []
  7. Knowler, W. C., Barrett-Connor, E., Fowler, S. E., Hamman, R. F., Lachin, J. M., Walker, E. A., et al. (2002). Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. New England Journal of Medicine, 346, 393–403. []
  8. DREAM (Diabetes REduction Assessment with ramipril and rosiglitazone Medication) Trial Investigators Gerstein, H. C., Yusuf, S., Bosch, J., Poque, J., et al. (2006). Effect of rosiglitazone on the frequency of diabetes in patients with impaired glucose tolerance or impaired fasting glucose: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet, 368, 1096–1105. []
  9. K. Ebihara, A. Nakajima, Effect of acetic acid and vinegar on blood glucose and insulin responses to orally administered sucrose and starch, Agric. Biol. Chem. 52 (1988) 1311–1312. []
  10. F. Brighenti, G. Castellani, L. Benini, M.C. Casiraghi, E. Leopardi, R. Crovetti, et al., Effect of neutralized and native vinegar on blood glucose and acetate responses to a mixed meal in healthy subjects, Eur. J. Clin. Nutr. 49 (1995) 242–247. []
  11. C.S. Johnston, A.J. Buller, Vinegar and peanut products ascomplementary foods to reduce postprandial glycaemia, J. Am. Diet. Assoc. 105 (2005) 1939–1942. []
  12. E. Ostman, Y. Granfeldt, L. Persson, I. Bjo¨ rck, Vinegar supplementation lowers glucose and insulin responses and increases satiety after a bread meal in healthy subjects, Eur. J. Clin. Nutr. 59 (2005) 983–988. []
  13. Ann Nutr Metab. 2010;56(1):74-9. doi: 10.1159/000272133. Examination of the antiglycemic properties of vinegar in healthy adults. Johnston CS1, Steplewska I, Long CA, Harris LN, Ryals RH. []
  14. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2009 May;84(2):e15-7. doi: 10.1016/j.diabres.2009.02.005. Epub 2009 Mar 9. Preliminary evidence that regular vinegar ingestion favorably influences hemoglobin A1c values in individuals with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Johnston CS, White AM, Kent SM. []
  15. Discussed previously: HbA1c & Plant-Based Diets: Warning – Disturbing Images []
  16. Nutr Res. 2009 Dec;29(12):846-9. doi: 10.1016/j.nutres.2009.10.021. Vinegar lacks antiglycemic action on enteral carbohydrate absorption in human subjects. Salbe AD, Johnston CS, Buyukbese MA, Tsitouras PD, Harman SM. []
  17. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2015 Jun;69(6):734-9. doi: 10.1038/ejcn.2014.289. Epub 2015 Jan 28. The role of acetic acid on glucose uptake and blood flow rates in the skeletal muscle in humans with impaired glucose tolerance. Mitrou P, Petsiou E, Papakonstantinou E, Maratou E, Lambadiari V, Dimitriadis P, Spanoudi F, Raptis SA, Dimitriadis G. []
  18. J Diabetes Res. 2015;2015:175204. doi: 10.1155/2015/175204. Epub 2015 May 6. Vinegar Consumption Increases Insulin-Stimulated Glucose Uptake by the Forearm Muscle in Humans with Type 2 Diabetes. Mitrou P, Petsiou E, Papakonstantinou E, Maratou E, Lambadiari V, Dimitriadis P, Spanoudi F, Raptis SA, Dimitriadis G. []
  19. THE EFFECT OF VINEGAR ON POSTPRANDIAL GLYCEMIA: DOES THE AMOUNT MATTER? Kahraman, N. Kuzeyli; Mesci, B.; Oguz, A.; Tamer, G.; Kahraman, C.; Sagun, G.; Kilic, D. Coksert; Akalin, A.. Acta Endocrinologica (1841-0987);Oct-Dec 2011, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p577. []
  20. Starting Out – The WFPB Larder []

Plant Milks Are Churning Up The Ground

A recent article in the Daily Telegraph 1 about the rise of Oatly dairy alternatives 2 revealed more about the rise of interest in plant-based alternatives to calf growth fluid 3 (‘cow’s milk’ to most people).

  • Google reports continued growth over the past 5 years in web searches for alternative milks
  • Veganuary continues to record increased participants
  • Oatly employs ~300 people
  • during 2015-17, UK [and US] sales of cow’s milk rose just 0.3% whilst non-dairy milk grew 9.4% 4
    • Oatly 2018 UK sales were £18m, up 89% from 2017
    • Oatly 2018 global sales were £87m – they’re hoping to double this in 2019
  • in 2015, Oatly was sued by Sweden’s dairy association for the brand’s advertising slogans, which included “It’s like milk, but made for humans” and “Wow, no cow!”

  • demand for Oatly – particularly its “Barista edition” milk 5 – is so high, supplies ran dry last year
  • a glass of dairy milk produces almost three times the greenhouse gas emissions of any non-dairy milk 6
  • cow’s milk is the most environmentally harmful based on three key factors: land use, water use and carbon emissions 6
  • buying a carton of oat milk instead of cow’s milk has an immediate positive impact on the environment
  • Oatly products are also doing well in China, where a significant number of people are lactose intolerant
  • Pettersson, Oatly CEO, says: “Our mission is not to turn people vegan, it’s about everyone making small changes to their diet that will ultimately benefit the planet our children will inherit

Final thoughts

Previous blogs have looked at other dairy alternatives 7 8 , and how human health may be damaged by dairy consumption 9 10 However, because of the entrenched misinformation that the dairy industry has been pushing for decades, the vast majority of people still believe that good-old dairy simply must be good for our health, in spite of all the scientific evidence to the contrary 11 12 .

Again, we looked previously 13 at how governments are trying (and succeeding, for the time being) to stop producers of dairy alternatives from even being able to use common words such as ‘milk’, ‘dairy’, ‘cheese’, ‘cream’ etc. Big Dairy will not easily give up the fight against dairy alternatives, even if it means strong-arming governments to push through legislation that basically trademarks everyday words.

However, in time, I suspect that all dairy companies will have to make some transition to producing non-dairy alternatives if, that is, they want to share the financial benefits of this growing market.

And we all know how attractive profits are to Big Business, even if it means they are forced to sell something that’s actually good for human health and not just for their balance sheets!


References

  1. Daily Telegraph 17 January 2019: Wow, no cow! The rise and rise of oat milk manufacturer Oatly by Sophie Christie []
  2. Oatly Products []
  3. ‘Cow’s milk’ as baby calf growth fluid: video with Michael Klaper []
  4. Mintel dairy/non-dairy sales []
  5. Oatly Barista edition milk []
  6. Science. 2018 Jun 1;360(6392):987-992. doi: 10.1126/science.aaq0216. Reducing food’s environmental impacts through producers and consumers. Poore J, Nemecek T. [] []
  7. Which Is the Best Non-dairy Milk? []
  8. Isn’t Plant Milk a Processed Food? []
  9. Cow’s Milk – But It Looks So Innocent… []
  10. If You Want Enough Calcium, Forget Milk []
  11. PCRM: Health Concerns About Dairy
    Avoid the Dangers of Dairy with a Plant-Based Diet []
  12. Nutritionfacts: Dairy []
  13. Never Doubt The Power of Big Farming – EU Law Being Milked []